What to write
- Who you are, which home (address and land registry details), the date of the deed and of the handover of the keys, and the price.
- The defect: when you found it, what the surveyor's report says and why it could not be seen at the viewing.
- Why the seller knew about it, if you have evidence: work done shortly before the sale that hid the defect, messages, answers given before the deed.
- What you are asking for: the cost of the repairs or a price reduction, or giving the home back for a refund, and a deadline to reply, for example 15 days.
How to send it and what it changes for the deadlines
- Spain: a burofax with certified text, which proves receipt, date and full text (Ley Orgánica 1/2025, art. 10). If it proposes a negotiation, the letter counts as the compulsory attempt before going to court, also between private individuals, and pauses the 6 months; if no written reply arrives within 30 days, the deadlines start again (arts. 5 and 7). Towards a business, a written complaint is enough (seventh additional provision).
- Italy: a raccomandata con ricevuta di ritorno or PEC. It counts as the report of the defect, to be sent within 8 days of discovery (Codice civile, art. 1495), and as a formal demand it interrupts the limitation period: a new year starts that day (arts. 2943 and 2945). For serious defects in a new home, the report must be made within a year of discovery (art. 1669).
- France: a lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception («mise en demeure»). It does not stop the 2 years of art. 1648: they are interrupted by a claim before a judge, even in summary proceedings (Code civil, art. 2241), and suspended by an expert survey ordered by the judge before the case (art. 2239). For a new home, in the first year the letter to the contractor triggers the completion guarantee and the dommages-ouvrage insurance (art. 1792-6; Code des assurances, art. L242-1).
If the seller does not reply
- Spain: if no reply arrives within 30 days, the compulsory attempt has been made and you can go to court with proof of the request; up to €2,000 without a lawyer or procurador (Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil, arts. 23 and 31).
- Italy: for a home the tribunale decides, not the giudice di pace (Codice di procedura civile, art. 7). Between private individuals, before claiming up to €50,000 in court, assisted negotiation with a lawyer is required (D.L. 132/2014, art. 3); compulsory mediation does not cover the sale, but it does apply against the insurer of the ten-year policy (D.Lgs. 28/2010, art. 5).
- France: for claims up to €5,000, before going to court you need an attempt at conciliation, mediation or a participatory procedure (Code de procédure civile, art. 750-1). For a serious defect, people often ask the judge for an expert survey (référé-expertise), which suspends the deadlines (Code civil, art. 2239).
Mistakes to avoid
Do not wait for the full report before writing: in Spain the 6 months run from handover, not from discovery, and in Italy the 8 days start when you find the defect. Do not remove the defect with repairs before you have documented it, except urgent ones. Do not sign a settlement in which you give up your claims without reading it carefully. A sober letter with facts, dates and articles works better than a long, angry one.
This guide explains the laws of Spain, Italy and France on homes bought with a hidden defect in plain words: it is not legal advice. Homebuyer Defender does not inspect buildings or price repairs: for the defect itself you need a surveyor or a builder. If you receive a court document, see a lawyer straight away.
Sources
- Italy, Codice civile, art. 1495 (Normattiva)
- Italy, Codice civile, art. 1669 (Normattiva)
- Italy, Codice civile, art. 2943 (Normattiva)
- Italy, Codice civile, art. 2945 (Normattiva)
- Italy, Codice di procedura civile, art. 7 (Normattiva)
- Italy, D.L. 132/2014, art. 3 (Normattiva)
- Italy, D.Lgs. 28/2010, art. 5 (Normattiva)
- Spain, Ley Orgánica 1/2025 (BOE)
- Spain, Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil (BOE)
- France, Code civil, art. 1648 (Légifrance)
- France, Code civil, art. 1792-6 (Légifrance)
- France, Code civil, art. 2239 (Légifrance)
- France, Code civil, art. 2241 (Légifrance)
- France, Code des assurances, art. L242-1 (Légifrance)
- France, Code de procédure civile, art. 750-1 (Légifrance)
Laws checked on 15 November 2026 against the official texts of Spain, Italy and France.