Appealing a traffic fine in Italy: Prefetto or Giudice di pace?
The two appeals against an Italian fine: 60 days and free before the Prefetto, 30 days and €43 before the Giudice di pace. Which to choose.
Multa Giusta guide
Since 12 July 2026, a speed camera in Italy is homologated if it is one of the 15 models in Annex B of the Ministry decree of 8 June 2026, or if it has a new homologation decree. If your fine is from that day or later and the model isn't there, you have a strong ground for an appeal. For earlier fines, a view of Italy's Court of Cassation counts, «approved» does not mean «homologated», but not all judges agree.
The decree of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport of 8 June 2026 sets out how devices that measure speed are homologated, calibrated and checked. It was published in the Gazzetta Ufficiale no. 159 of 11 July 2026 and has been in force since the following day, 12 July 2026.
Its Annex B lists 15 models approved in earlier years: devices that conform to these models «are deemed homologated» (art. 6). A device of any other model needs a new homologation decree to measure speed. The 15 models are:
The decree applies from 12 July 2026 and says nothing about earlier fines. For those, an order of the Court of Cassation counts (no. 10505 of 18 April 2024): a device that was only «approved» by the Ministry is not «homologated», and its reading is not enough for a fine. Not all judges follow it, so it is a «disputed» ground: you can try it, but the outcome is not certain.
An example: a 50 km/h limit and 65 km/h measured. The speed that counts is 60 km/h, i.e. 10 km/h over the limit: from €42 and no penalty points. If the verbale deducted only 2 km/h, you end up 13 km/h over the limit: from €173 and 3 points.
If something is missing from the verbale, you can ask for it with a request for access to the records (accesso agli atti). It doesn't change the appeal deadlines, so send it right away.
From the day the verbale was served on you, you have 60 days to appeal to the Prefetto and 30 days to appeal to the Giudice di pace, or 60 if you live outside Italy. If you pay the fine, even with the discount, you can no longer appeal. How to choose: Prefetto or Giudice di pace.
This guide explains the law in force in plain words: it isn't legal advice. For large fines, or fines that suspend your driving licence, it's worth asking a lawyer.
Articles checked on 4 November 2026 on Normattiva and in the Gazzetta Ufficiale, Italy's official gazette.
The two appeals against an Italian fine: 60 days and free before the Prefetto, 30 days and €43 before the Giudice di pace. Which to choose.
An Italian fine must be served within 90 days, 360 if you live abroad. How the days are counted and what changes with a rental car.
Multa Giusta reads the model, decree and calibration and tells you whether there is a ground. You pay €9.99 only if the fine can be challenged and you want the appeal documents.